How Did Davy Die? And Why Do We Care So Much?: Commemorative Edition (Elma Dill Russell Spencer Series in the West and Southwest) Review

How Did Davy Die And Why Do We Care So Much: Commemorative Edition (Elma Dill Russell Spencer Series in the West and Southwest)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
Are you looking to buy How Did Davy Die And Why Do We Care So Much: Commemorative Edition (Elma Dill Russell Spencer Series in the West and Southwest)? Here is the right place to find the great deals. we can offer discounts of up to 90% on How Did Davy Die And Why Do We Care So Much: Commemorative Edition (Elma Dill Russell Spencer Series in the West and Southwest). Check out the link below:

>> Click Here to See Compare Prices and Get the Best Offers

How Did Davy Die And Why Do We Care So Much: Commemorative Edition (Elma Dill Russell Spencer Series in the West and Southwest) ReviewA bit of a sensational populist tome and lightweight scholarly treatment, Dan Kilgore's book begins, with the very title, to telegraph it's intent: to deflate the myth of "Davy" Crockett. "Davy" being the name of the manufactured mythical creation of pulp writers who bears little resemblance to the historical David Crockett and this is the sphere where Kilgore operates. Myth Buster. Davy Crockett and Alamo myth busting has, in it's small way become a publishing craze. From the opening pages it is clear that once more, David Crockett's life story is at the mercy of writers for profit.
It is a breezy read though, with prose that easily glides through the numerous dry dates, figures and names that might be unfamiliar to the lay reader. Crockett's life is characterized in a few opening paragraphs, highlighting his lack of accomplishment in Congress, his use as a political pawn by the Whigs and his own obsession with his public image during his period in Washington. Kilgore relies heavily on the James A. Shackford biography, with it's own perfunctory conclusions, especially in regard to Crockett's motivations in Texas. All in all a rather one-dimensional and unflattering portrait of an historical figure, now made all the more tragic by a death not in the heat of battle but afterwards as a prisoner.Kilgore relies primarily and leans most heavily on the controversial De La Pena memoirs. It is important to note that in the original De la Pena memoir Crockett's name is not mentioned at all. The Crockett reference was inserted later into a second rewritten version some years later, and was subject to some questionable translation practices in the 1950's, when the papers appeared on the scene with little or no provenance. Amazingly, De la Pena's credibility as an eyewitness is never questioned by Kilgore. These papers, while being an extremely valuable source of study have advantages and disadvantages like any historical document. Like all primary and secondary sources they should be examined with a conscientious eye and and not without a touch of skepticism. One cannot simply accept an historical document at face value and it is here where Kilgore's scholarship falls most astonishingly short. When the leaps of faith become more numerous than fact finding, the very pages of the book begin to sag in my hand as I turn each page more slowly.
Kilgore's unquestioned use of discredited contemporary sources (Sgt. Beccara and Ramon Caro, Santa Anna's secretary, top this list by many reputable Alamo historians) and the use of numerous unnamed sources is entirely unscholarly, highly speculative and ultimately frustrating. While it seems very likely that several Texians were executed after the battle the argument that Crockett was among them is weak at best when the evidence is carefully examined in historical context. This is something which Kilgore does not do but manages to flesh out a whole book anyway. Its' value as a compendium of sources (both good and bad) make it worthwhile for the connoisseur but the analysis can be depthless and incomplete.For the record, I am not a fan of John Wayne, Fess Parker or Alamo "mythology" and/or hero worship. The manner of Crockett's death is not at all important to me however the manner in which Alamo history is examined is very important.
And that's why I care.
How Did Davy Die And Why Do We Care So Much: Commemorative Edition (Elma Dill Russell Spencer Series in the West and Southwest) Overview

Want to learn more information about How Did Davy Die And Why Do We Care So Much: Commemorative Edition (Elma Dill Russell Spencer Series in the West and Southwest)?

>> Click Here to See All Customer Reviews & Ratings Now

0 comments:

Post a Comment