John Tyler, the Accidental President Review

John Tyler, the Accidental President
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
Are you looking to buy John Tyler, the Accidental President? Here is the right place to find the great deals. we can offer discounts of up to 90% on John Tyler, the Accidental President. Check out the link below:

>> Click Here to See Compare Prices and Get the Best Offers

John Tyler, the Accidental President ReviewI eagerly awaited the release of this book for several months and purchased a copy as soon as it was available. Maybe my expectations were out of whack, but I was a little disappointed.
It was well-written and had some good analysis of a much (and somewhat unfairly) maligned president, but I was expecting some NEW analysis or NEW scholarship regarding President Tyler. To me, this just seemed like a slightly updated version of Oliver Chitwood's (still) definitive biography of Tyler. I was hoping Crapol would replace Chitwood as THE word on Tyler, but he didn't.
At 283 pages, this is not a definitive biography. It details Tyler's personal and family life only briefly, focusing heavily on his public life. Whereas Chitwood's premise was that Tyler was steadfast in his championing of strict construction of the Constitution and Jeffersonian states' rights principles and no one should have been surprised or disappointed by his actions as president, which Chitwood claimed were wholly consistent with those principles; Crapol's premise is that Tyler frequently compromised those principles when it served his political interests--primarily expansionism through the annexation of Texas and new uses of executive power to get around areas reserved to Congress by a strict reading of the Constitution. While these (clearly correct) conclusions were new, this book just seemed like Chitwood run through a 21st Century filter. Nothing wrong with that--just not what I hoped it would be.
This is by no means a poor book, and I am glad it was written. I think there should be modern bios of all of our presidents available. If you have not read Chitwood and want a brief biography of Tyler, I would recommend this book (it has very little competition). But if you are looking for a definitive biography of John Tyler, I think you still have to go with the unabashedly apologetic Chitwood. I'm now going to try the out-of-print dual biography of John and Julia Tyler by Robert Seager. Maybe it will be the best of the lot?John Tyler, the Accidental President Overview

Want to learn more information about John Tyler, the Accidental President?

>> Click Here to See All Customer Reviews & Ratings Now

0 comments:

Post a Comment